Does Saudization help or hurt startups?
The private sector in Saudi Arabia is now employing more Saudi
citizens than ever before. In the past 30 months since the Ministry
of Labor introduced new reforms, the number of Saudi citizens
working for private companies has doubled, the Labor Minister
announced two weeks ago.
Yet can its reforms reach startups, the sector of businesses most
poised to influence new job creation?
Perhaps, two founders say. The new reforms, introduced in 2011 and
2012, which included stricter penalties for failing to meet
Saudization quotas and fines on the number of foreign employees
that exceed Saudis, have helped raise numbers of Saudi employees.
Yet these reforms have mostly affected industries such as
construction, which rely heavily on inexpensive foreign laborers,
says Mazen Saleh AlDarrab, founder and CEO of eCommerce SEA, a Saudi company
that helps build e-commerce ventures.
The challenge, he says, is that the measures don't affect
skilled workers “in the tech industries” who usually earn
higher salaries.
“The issue with the program,” AlDarrab writes over e-mail, “is that
at this stage, it focuses on entry-level jobs… not taking into
consideration [corporate] and highly paid positions.” So, while
these initiatives might make more relatively low-paying jobs
available to Saudis, there remain few high-level positions to be
had, which, in the long term, could encourage brain drain.
However, AlDarrab says, there has been a positive effect in more
mature market segments like the food and retail industries, where
he’s noticed an increase in monthly wages.
The reforms have also led to an increase in “women-run,
female-centric businesses like intimate wear, accessories, and
perfumes,” says Sinan Khatib, a serial entrepreneur who has
launched Velvetty, an
offline private shopping club, and Bite Me, a gourmet sandwich shop in
Riyadh.
A shift in mentality might further accelerate the trend, Khatib continues. “There have been some efforts to start instilling in the population the mentality that there’s nothing wrong with earning an honest living working in a service-based profession. I expect this social stigma to begin coming down purely for practical reasons and the need for greater employment [rates] amongst the youth.”
Today, around 30-40% of working-age Saudis are employed or
actively seeking work, and only 12% of the total Saudi population
participate in the workforce. As of 2012, 37% of the Saudi
population was under the age of
14.
The hope is that if the government can encourage companies to
create more highly skilled jobs, while training its current Saudi
employees to enter highly-skilled jobs, it will be able to reduce
the country's dependence upon oil, and stem the rise of youth
unemployment. Incubators and accelerators, like the BADIR ICT
Technology Incubator, the KAUST
Venture Lab, and Flat6Labs
Jeddah, may be able to support the transition.
Nina Curley contributed to this report.